INDIANA 1988 Cold Case Solved — The Killer Left DNA With His Taunting Notes
On Good Friday, April 1, 1988, eight-year-old April Tinsley went back for her umbrella in her own Fort Wayne, Indiana, neighborhood — and never got there. Investigators kept biological evidence from her clothing that held one unknown man's DNA. In 1990 someone wrote on a barn door that he had killed her; in 2004, notes left for little girls came with biological material that matched the same profile. For thirty years, the DNA had no name.
This is the full story: April's life, the investigation that never stopped, the FBI's 2009 surge, the 2015 DNA prediction, and the 2018 genetic genealogy (Parabon NanoLabs, CeCe Moore, GEDmatch under its rules at the time) that pointed to two brothers — then the trash pull and lab comparison that confirmed one of them: John D. Miller.
🔔 Subscribe for more cold cases solved by DNA.
💬 Should police be allowed to search public DNA databases to solve cases like this? Tell us in the comments.
CHAPTERS
0:00 Cold open: the evidence they kept
1:49 Fort Wayne, 1988 — April Tinsley
4:47 Good Friday
7:30 Three days
10:38 One unknown man
13:48 May 21, 1990 — the barn
15:46 The years between
18:29 The 2004 notes
21:10 “Highly solvable” — the FBI, 2009
25:38 A face from DNA
29:30 Two brothers — the genetic genealogy
34:06 The trash, and a name
40:58 The courtroom
49:26 What remains
CASE STATUS (as of October 2026)
John D. Miller pleaded guilty to murder and child molesting on December 7, 2018, and was sentenced on December 21, 2018, to 80 years in prison. He died in the custody of the Indiana Department of Correction on September 4, 2025, at 66.
His brother, the other man the family-tree research pointed to, was never accused and is not named. The genealogy-database relatives and the families who received the 2004 notes are not named.
SOURCES (reporting this video relies on)
FBI (2009 releases) · Allen County court records / probable cause affidavit as reported · Indiana Department of Correction · Indiana State Police · Parabon NanoLabs (2015) · The Journal Gazette · The News-Sentinel · WANE 15 · WPTA 21Alive · FOX 55 · WTHR · WISH-TV · WRTV · AP · CBS News · NBC News · Inside Edition · Three Rivers Art Center for Kids (2018 interview with Janet Tinsley and Kim).
CREDITS
Photos of April Tinsley: family and school photos released to the media. Barn message photo: FBI. News photos and short clips (≤10 seconds per source video, one clip per video) are used for commentary and reporting and credited on screen and here: FOX 55, Inside Edition, The News-Sentinel, Three Rivers Art Center for Kids, WANE 15, WISH-TV, WPTA 21Alive, WRTV, WTHR. Logos cropped.
Wikimedia Commons: "Downtown Fort Wayne, Indiana Skyline from Old Fort, May 2014" by Momoneymoproblemz (Public domain) · "Fort Wayne - May 2008 - 04" by kristinafh (CC BY 2.0) · "Cortes del Condado de Allen, Fort Wayne, Indiana, Estados Unidos, 2012-11-12, DD 01" by Diego Delso (CC BY-SA 3.0) · "Allen County Indiana Courthouse (Ft Wayne)" by Charles W. Chapman (CC BY-SA 4.0) · "Cupola details of Allen County Courthouse in Fort Wayne Indiana" by Detsom (CC BY 4.0) · "Allen County Courthouse, 715 South Calhoun Street, 1997 (Fort Wayne, Ind.) - DPLA - c0f1c2df03076a0e5444867eb1a56bd4" by Dan Francis/Mardan Photography; Indiana Landmarks (CC BY 4.0) · "Grabill, Indiana" by Chris Flook (CC BY-SA 4.0) · "Spencerville Covered Bridge" by Rod Detty (CC BY 2.0) · "Parkview Field, Fort Wayne, Indiana, Estados Unidos, 2012-11-12, DD 01" by Diego Delso (CC BY-SA 3.0) · "Miser Farm, 4838 County Road 22, 2002 (DeKalb County, Ind.) - DPLA - 93871786eea929107a8c64c9777f5464" by Indiana Landmarks (CC BY 4.0) · "Hamman Farm, 0949 County Road 35, 2002 (DeKalb County, Ind.) - DPLA - 979586cac4fd7234a78bc6e69a55691b" by Indiana Landmarks (CC BY 4.0) · "Long Farm, 6377 County Road 7, 2002 (DeKalb County, Ind.) - DPLA - f8c9f13c5b84af5b80ad420d63b2d609" by Indiana Landmarks (CC BY 4.0) · "Liberty Drive in Fort Wayne, Indiana - 2008" by kristinafh (CC BY 2.0) · "WILDWOOD PARK HISTORIC DISTRICT, FORT WAYNE, ALLEN COUNTY, IN" by JERRYE & ROY KLOTZ, M.D. (CC BY-SA 4.0) · "Foster Parkway, Fort Wayne" by Nyttend (Public domain).
Stock footage: Pexels (Pexels License). Maps: © OpenStreetMap contributors.
Music by Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com), licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 — "Lightless Dawn", "Lasting Hope", "Long Note One", "Heavy Interlude", "Night Cave", "Ghost Story", "Long Note Two", "Interloper", "Dark Walk", "Echoes of Time v2", "Ossuary 6 - Air", "Gathering Darkness", "Dark Times", "Despair and Triumph".
Sound effects: CC0 / public domain / our own.
Graphics marked "illustration" are our own designs, not evidence or lab results. Family trees and DNA graphics are schematic; no private relatives are shown. The Snapshot images are forensic predictions, not photographs.
#ColdCase #DNA #TrueCrime #GeneticGenealogy #AprilTinsley #FortWayne #Indiana
コメント 読み込み中…